Dave Yadallee's personal blog

Here's a review of Doctor Who: The Edge of Destruction / The Brink of

Disaster (sometimes listed as simply "The Edge of Destruction"):



Background



Airing in February 1964, "The Edge of Destruction"

(originally titled "Inside the Ship") is the third Doctor Who serial

and the first written by Script Editor David Whitaker. It marks

a turning point in the show, introducing a more psychological

and character-driven approach to storytelling compared to the historical

adventures of the first two serials.



Story



The TARDIS crew – the Doctor, Susan, Ian, and Barbara – find themselves

disoriented and suspicious of each other. A broken safety switch on the

TARDIS disrupts the crew's mental state, leading to paranoia, fear,

and even violence. The Doctor must not only fix the TARDIS

but also navigate the fractured relationships within his crew.



Review



"The Edge of Destruction" is a unique and experimental story in Doctor Who

history. Here are some key points to consider:



Psychological Thriller: This serial departs from the sci-fi adventure

format of the previous stories. It delves into the psychological effects

of the malfunctioning TARDIS, creating a tense and claustrophobic

atmosphere.



Character Development: "The Edge of Destruction" focuses heavily

on character development. We see the Doctor's resourcefulness

and his struggle to maintain control. The companions also grapple

with fear and suspicion, revealing their inner strengths and weaknesses.



Mixed Pacing: The story starts slow, establishing the mystery

and the characters' growing unease. The pace picks up as the situation

becomes more desperate.



Controversial Elements: Some viewers find the acting and dialogue a bit

over-the-top, especially the Doctor's uncharacteristically aggressive

behaviour.



Reception



Positive: Praised for its originality, psychological depth, and focus

on character development. It's also considered a turning point for the

show's direction.



Negative: Criticised for its slow pacing, melodramatic acting,

and departure from the established format.



Overall Thoughts



"The Edge of Destruction" is a bold experiment in Doctor Who history.

While not without its flaws, it offers a unique and thought-provoking

story that delves into the characters' psyches. It represents

a significant step in the show's evolution from pure sci-fi adventure

to a more complex and character-driven format.



Would I recommend watching it?:



If you're interested in the history of Doctor Who and seeing the show evolve,

"The Edge of Destruction" is a valuable watch. However, if you prefer

fast-paced adventures with clear heroes and villains, you might find it

slow and confusing.



Here are some additional points to consider:



The Historical Context: Remember, this serial aired in 1964. Television

production values and storytelling techniques have changed significantly

since then.

The Doctor's Character: This is still the early days of the First Doctor.

His personality and relationship with his companions are still being

established. He might come across as more ruthless or even cruel compared

to later incarnations.



Ultimately, whether you enjoy "The Edge of Destruction" depends on your

personal preferences. It's a unique and experimental story that

offers a different flavour of Doctor Who.

"Doctor Who - The Macra Terror" is a classic four-part serial from the Fourth

Season of the original series, first broadcast in 1967. Set on a futuristic

human colony, the story follows the Doctor and his companions as they uncover

a sinister plot orchestrated by giant crab-like creatures known as the Macra.



Here's a breakdown of each episode individually:



Episode 1:

The first episode effectively sets up the premise of the story, introducing the

idyllic colony of New New York and the strange occurrences that hint at darker

forces at play. The tension builds steadily as the Doctor and his companions

investigate the mysterious disappearances and encounter the mind-controlling

Episode 2 continues to ramp up the suspense as the Doctor and his companions

delve deeper into the secrets of the colony. The introduction of the Macra as

the primary antagonists adds a sense of danger and urgency to the story. The

episode effectively explores themes of conformity and manipulation, showcasing

the insidious nature of the Macra's control over the colony's inhabitants.

Despite some pacing issues, it's a solid installment

that keeps viewers engaged.

Rating: 7/10



Episode 3:

This episode sees the tension reach its peak as the Doctor and his companions

confront the Macra head-on. The action sequences are well-executed, and the

stakes feel higher than ever as the truth behind the colony's facade is

revealed. The Doctor's resourcefulness and quick thinking are on full display

as he devises a plan to defeat the Macra and free the colony from their

influence. Overall, it's a thrilling installment that delivers on both suspense

and excitement.

Rating: 9/10



Episode 4:

The final episode brings the story to a satisfying conclusion as the Doctor

and his companions confront the true masterminds behind the Macra's plot. The

resolution is both action-packed and emotionally resonant, with moments of

sacrifice and heroism from the main characters. The episode ties up loose ends

effectively and leaves viewers with a sense of closure, while also setting the

stage for future adventures. Overall, it's a strong ending to a memorable

serial.

Rating: 8/10



Overall, "Doctor Who - The Macra Terror" is a gripping and atmospheric serial

that effectively combines elements of science fiction and horror. While some

episodes may have pacing issues, the story remains engaging throughout,

making it a classic installment in the Doctor Who canon.



Total Rating: 8/10