Dave Yadallee's personal blog

Both Tom Baker's 4th Doctor and David Tennant's 10th Doctor are incredibly

popular among Doctor Who fans, but for different reasons.

Here's a breakdown of their strengths and why they resonate with viewers:



Tom Baker (4th Doctor):



Strengths:

Iconic Status: Baker's portrayal is arguably the most iconic Doctor. His

long tenure (seven seasons) and flamboyant costume cemented him

in popular culture.



He was both alien and charming.



Exploration and Wonder: Baker's era captured the spirit of exploration and

wonder inherent in Doctor Who. His stories often emphasised fantastical

as the quintessential Doctor Who.



David Tennant (10th Doctor):



Strengths:

Modern Appeal: Tennant brought Doctor Who back to mainstream popularity in

the revived series. His Doctor was charismatic, heroic, and had a strong

emotional connection with his companions.

Darkness and Vulnerability: While Tennant's Doctor had a heroic side, he

also grappled with inner darkness and the burden of his long life. This

complexity made him relatable.

Fast-Paced Adventures: The revived series offered a more modern approach to

storytelling, with faster pacing and higher production values. Tennant's

Doctor thrived in this format.



Popularity: David Tennant is hugely popular among newer fans,

particularly those who watched the revived series during his tenure.

He's often seen as a gateway to the wider world of Doctor Who.



Who is More Popular?



It's difficult to say definitively who is more popular. Here are some factors

to consider:



Generational Bias: Fans who grew up with Baker tend to favour him,

while those who started with Tennant might lean towards him.

Accessibility: The revived series with Tennant is more readily

available than classic Doctor Who with Baker. This can influence

perception of popularity.



Ultimately, both Tom Baker and David Tennant are fantastic Doctors who have

brought joy to millions of fans. Their unique strengths and the eras they

represent ensure their continued popularity

within the vast Doctor Who universe.

"Doctor Who - The Underwater Menace" is a four-part serial from the Fourth

Season of the original series, first broadcast in 1967. The story revolves

around the Doctor and his companions landing on the lost underwater city of

Atlantis, where they encounter a megalomaniacal scientist intent on raising

Atlantis from the depths of the ocean.



Episode 1 introduces the intriguing premise of an underwater civilisation,

showcasing impressive set design and atmosphere. However, subsequent episodes

struggle to maintain momentum, with the plot becoming increasingly convoluted

and the pacing uneven.



One of the standout elements of "The Underwater Menace" is the memorable

performance of Joseph Furst as Professor Zaroff, the deranged scientist

determined to conquer the world. Furst brings a charismatic yet sinister

presence to the role, elevating the story whenever he appears on screen.



Unfortunately, the serial suffers from production limitations, particularly

evident in the underwater sequences, which are hampered by primitive special

effects. Additionally, the characterisation of the Doctor and his companions

feels somewhat underdeveloped, with less focus on their interactions and

dynamics compared to other serials.



While "The Underwater Menace" has its flaws, including a somewhat lackluster

resolution, it still offers moments of entertainment and showcases the

creativity of Doctor Who's early years.



Episode 1: 6/10

Episode 2: 5/10

Episode 3: 4/10

Episode 4: 5/10



Overall Rating: 5/10