Google Gemini reviews Doctor Who - Planet of the Giants
Here's a review of Doctor Who: The Planets of Giants,
the first serial of the show's second season,
to help you decide if you'd like to watch it:
Story
The TARDIS malfunctions during flight, shrinking the Doctor,
Susan, Ian, and Barbara to the size of insects. They land
on a seemingly normal Earth, only to discover the human
inhabitants are giants oblivious to their presence.
The companions must find a way to communicate
with the humans and get themselves back to normal
size while avoiding being crushed or exterminated.
Review
Strengths:
Unique Premise: The concept of being shrunk to a miniature
size creates a unique and suspenseful situation. The serial
explores the dangers of a familiar world from a new perspective.
Early Companion Dynamics: We see Ian and Barbara working
together to protect Susan and find solutions.
Their resourcefulness and growing trust in the Doctor are on display.
Social Commentary (Subtle for the Time):
The serial touches on themes of power dynamics
and the exploitation of weaker beings, though these themes
are more subtle compared to later Doctor Who stories.
Weaknesses:
Limited Special Effects: The special effects used to depict
the shrunken characters and the giant world might seem primitive
by modern standards.
Slow Pacing in Parts: The narrative can feel slow at times,
especially during exposition scenes explaining the situation.
Reused Plot Elements: The concept of the Doctor
and his companions being shrunk was used in an earlier
episode ("The Shrinking Man"). This might make the plot
feel less original for some viewers.
Reception:
Positive: Praised for its unique premise,
early companions dynamics, and subtle social commentary.
Some fans also enjoy the sense of wonder and suspense.
Negative: Criticized for its slow pacing, lack of action
in certain sections, and somewhat unconvincing special
effects for the giant world.
Overall Thoughts:
"The Planets of Giants" is an interesting story with a unique concept.
While the special effects might not hold up entirely today,
it offers a fun adventure and highlights the resourcefulness
of the companions.
Would I recommend watching it?
For Fans of Classic Doctor Who: 6/10
For Fans of Modern Doctor Who: 4/10
If you're a die-hard fan of classic Doctor Who
and enjoy stories with a sense of wonder
and unique premises, "The Planets of Giants"
is worth checking out. However, if you prefer
fast-paced adventures with cutting-edge special
effects, you might find it slow and less exciting.
Additional Points to Consider:
This serial introduced the work of incidental music
composer Dudley Simpson, who would go on to score
many classic Doctor Who stories.
If you enjoy "The Planets of Giants," you might
also appreciate other classic Doctor Who stories
that feature the companions working together
to solve problems in unique situations.
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to watch
"The Planets of Giants" depends on your personal preferences
and your tolerance for slower-paced storytelling with
a focus on companionship and inventiveness.
the first serial of the show's second season,
to help you decide if you'd like to watch it:
Story
The TARDIS malfunctions during flight, shrinking the Doctor,
Susan, Ian, and Barbara to the size of insects. They land
on a seemingly normal Earth, only to discover the human
inhabitants are giants oblivious to their presence.
The companions must find a way to communicate
with the humans and get themselves back to normal
size while avoiding being crushed or exterminated.
Review
Strengths:
Unique Premise: The concept of being shrunk to a miniature
size creates a unique and suspenseful situation. The serial
explores the dangers of a familiar world from a new perspective.
Early Companion Dynamics: We see Ian and Barbara working
together to protect Susan and find solutions.
Their resourcefulness and growing trust in the Doctor are on display.
Social Commentary (Subtle for the Time):
The serial touches on themes of power dynamics
and the exploitation of weaker beings, though these themes
are more subtle compared to later Doctor Who stories.
Weaknesses:
Limited Special Effects: The special effects used to depict
the shrunken characters and the giant world might seem primitive
by modern standards.
Slow Pacing in Parts: The narrative can feel slow at times,
especially during exposition scenes explaining the situation.
Reused Plot Elements: The concept of the Doctor
and his companions being shrunk was used in an earlier
episode ("The Shrinking Man"). This might make the plot
feel less original for some viewers.
Reception:
Positive: Praised for its unique premise,
early companions dynamics, and subtle social commentary.
Some fans also enjoy the sense of wonder and suspense.
Negative: Criticized for its slow pacing, lack of action
in certain sections, and somewhat unconvincing special
effects for the giant world.
Overall Thoughts:
"The Planets of Giants" is an interesting story with a unique concept.
While the special effects might not hold up entirely today,
it offers a fun adventure and highlights the resourcefulness
of the companions.
Would I recommend watching it?
For Fans of Classic Doctor Who: 6/10
For Fans of Modern Doctor Who: 4/10
If you're a die-hard fan of classic Doctor Who
and enjoy stories with a sense of wonder
and unique premises, "The Planets of Giants"
is worth checking out. However, if you prefer
fast-paced adventures with cutting-edge special
effects, you might find it slow and less exciting.
Additional Points to Consider:
This serial introduced the work of incidental music
composer Dudley Simpson, who would go on to score
many classic Doctor Who stories.
If you enjoy "The Planets of Giants," you might
also appreciate other classic Doctor Who stories
that feature the companions working together
to solve problems in unique situations.
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to watch
"The Planets of Giants" depends on your personal preferences
and your tolerance for slower-paced storytelling with
a focus on companionship and inventiveness.
Trackbacks
No Trackbacks
Comments
Display comments as Linear | Threaded